Rung Five

Ayurveda and cancer: traditional remedies, held to the same standard

We graded Ayurvedic herbs and practices exactly like everything else. Some have modest human evidence for easing treatment side effects or improving quality of life. None has been shown in human trials to treat or prevent cancer, and product quality is a real safety issue. Many other herbs, such as Sanjeevani and mangosteen, have only lab and animal results so far.

Buying Ayurvedic products safely

When researchers bought 193 Ayurvedic medicines online, about one in five contained lead, mercury or arsenic, and every one of those exceeded at least one daily safety limit. U.S.-made products were as likely to be contaminated as Indian-made ones. Rasa shastra formulas, which add metals on purpose, were more than twice as likely to contain them.

The risk shows up in people too: in a 2015 U.S. study of 115 people using Ayurvedic products, 40% had raised blood lead levels.

No U.S. state licenses Ayurvedic practitioners. In the UK, Cancer Research UK suggests choosing products registered under the Traditional Herbal Registration scheme.

Before taking any herb during treatment, tell your oncology team. Herbs can interact with chemotherapy, hormone therapy and surgery.

Prefer single-herb products with independent third-party testing. Avoid metal- or mineral-based formulas entirely, and products such as Carctol that claim to cure cancer.

Skip panchakarma cleansing during treatment. Its purging, enemas and bloodletting can cause infection and mineral imbalances, especially with low blood counts.

Yoga and meditation, from the same tradition, have better support for symptom relief than the herbs do.